Cole Hornsby, a 26-year-old man from Ohio, has been sentenced to 24 years to life in prison for the 2024 murder of his 40-year-old neighbor, Theodore “Ted” Block. The sentence follows Hornsby’s conviction on charges of murder and tampering with evidence. The fatal shooting occurred on April 16, 2024, when Hornsby shot Block in the back 12 times after a verbal altercation. Hornsby had previously claimed he acted in self-defense, but the jury found him guilty after hearing evidence that contradicted his defense.
Details of the Shooting and Argument
The incident began when Hornsby was firing a large muzzleloader rifle on his porch. Block, who was babysitting his grandchildren that evening, went over to Hornsby’s home and asked him to stop. An argument ensued, during which Block threatened to call the police before returning to his house. As Block walked away, Hornsby shot him in the back 12 times. Witnesses, including Block’s wife, Krissy, who was present during the shooting, confirmed the details. A forensic expert also testified that Hornsby shot Block while he was lying face down, further proving the brutality of the attack.
Sentencing and Family Impact
During Hornsby’s sentencing, the victim’s daughter, Alyiah Block, delivered an emotional statement, urging the court to impose the maximum sentence. She described Hornsby as a “coward” who took her father’s life for no reason. Despite Hornsby’s defense attorney suggesting a lighter sentence, the judge imposed the maximum penalty, ensuring Hornsby will remain behind bars for a long time. Prosecutor Connie Pillich praised the decision, calling the killing tragic and preventable. Hornsby’s actions have left a deep scar on Block’s family, and the community will now be safer with his sentence.
