Keymaree Fagin, 22, faces murder and related firearm charges in Marion County Superior Court for the December 23, 2025, shooting death of 21-year-old Logan Newman in Camby, Indiana. The altercation reportedly stemmed from a dispute over Fagin’s plan to divert his child’s Christmas money to a friend’s jail commissary account. Fagin allegedly shot Newman multiple times inside a vehicle at a park, causing a crash into a tennis court fence, before fleeing on foot.
Incident Details
Newman was driving with a woman passenger and another man when they picked up Fagin, who immediately displayed a stolen gun. After buying alcohol at Walmart, they went to the park on Blooming Grove Drive, where Fagin made the disputed call and grew agitated during the argument. Newman suggested fighting outside, but Fagin refused, stated “No, I’m going to shoot you,” and fired at close range.​
Charges and Arrest
Authorities charged Fagin with murder, pointing a firearm, and unlawful handgun possession due to a prior felony. Police responded around 12:50 p.m., detaining him nine minutes later based on surveillance footage showing gunfire from the car. Fagin admitted to the argument but claimed an external shooter.​
Court Timeline
The case was filed on Monday in Marion Superior Court, with a jury trial set for March 23, 2026. Newman, who was expecting his first child in July 2026 with his fiancée, died at the scene.​
