A South Carolina jury has been selected for the murder trial of Dyvonte Collins, with the trial expected to last through the end of the week. The selection process took place behind closed doors, with attorneys arguing for hours over what evidence should be allowed in the courtroom.
Details of the Crime
The prosecution accuses Collins of shooting and killing Adan Suarez while he was working at an apartment complex in West Ashley. According to court documents, the incident began when Collins approached Suarez’s brother during a roofing shift, asking for a lighter and a cigarette. Moments after receiving the lighter, Collins allegedly fired three shots into the passenger seat, killing Suarez at the scene. Investigators have not yet identified a clear motive for the shooting.
As a result, the jury will focus on physical evidence, including a gun, cellphone, surveillance video, DNA on the lighter, and witness testimony.
Debate Over Evidence
Following jury selection, attorneys argued behind closed doors over what evidence should be shown. Prosecutors sought to include photos from Collins’ phone that allegedly show him holding a gun months before the shooting, arguing that the photos challenge Collins’ claim that he was unarmed. They also requested crime scene images, including one of Suarez shot in the passenger seat with his seat belt on and the door still closed, arguing these images are critical for the jury to understand the circumstances of the crime. Additionally, prosecutors sought to have the victim’s brother and cousin remain in the courtroom during the trial, citing their status as victims under state law.
Defense attorneys, on the other hand, objected to the photos of Collins holding a gun, claiming that they were taken months before the incident and unfairly suggested a link to the crime. They also argued that some crime scene photos were overly graphic and could influence the jury’s opinion. Further, the defense opposed allowing both the brother and cousin in the courtroom, arguing it could impact their testimony if they were called to the stand.
Judge’s Ruling
Judge Maite Murphy ultimately ruled on the disputes:
- Photos of Collins holding a gun will be allowed.
- Crime scene photos can be shown, but only in black and white to reduce their graphic nature.
- Only the victim’s brother, not the cousin, will be allowed to remain in the courtroom during the trial.
Next Steps
The trial is set to resume with opening statements once jurors return. Since Suarez primarily spoke Spanish, the court has ensured a translator will be available throughout the proceedings to assist with translation.
This case continues to develop as the prosecution and defense prepare for the upcoming phase of the trial.
