A tragic case from Highland Park has finally reached a major turning point, bringing some closure to a family that lost a loved one in a brutal attack. The incident, which took place in 2022, has now ended with two men being found guilty of killing a father outside his home.
Jury Finds Two Men Guilty
A Lake County jury has convicted Nicholas Caban, 23, and Jacob Firestone, 22, in the killing of Matthew Ascaridis, a 45-year-old father.
Both men were found guilty on all charges, including second-degree murder, after a six-day trial. Prosecutors presented strong forensic and witness evidence to support the case.
What Happened That Night
The incident began late at night when Matthew Ascaridis and his wife were disturbed by loud noises near their home.
According to court details:
- The couple heard loud activity around 11 p.m.
- Ascaridis called police twice but was told there might be delays
- Around 1 a.m., he went out to check the situation himself
He reached Fort Sheridan Beach, where he encountered the two accused men.
A Violent Confrontation
Authorities say the situation quickly turned violent. Evidence presented in court showed that Ascaridis was brutally attacked.
Medical reports revealed:
- Severe trauma to the head
- A spinal cord injury usually seen in serious car accidents
- Multiple blows delivered with extreme force
The injuries were so serious that he was left unable to move.
Delayed Help Cost a Life
One of the most disturbing details of the case is that help was not called immediately.
Prosecutors said the attackers waited hours before contacting emergency services. During that time, Ascaridis was left alone on the beach, struggling to breathe.
By the time help arrived, he had already died.
Defence Claims Rejected
The accused initially claimed that Ascaridis had attacked them and that his injuries were caused by a fall.
However, investigators found:
- Medical evidence did not support their version
- DNA and forensic findings contradicted their claims
The jury ultimately rejected their defence and found them guilty.
Upcoming Sentencing
Both men now face prison sentences ranging from 4 to 20 years. They are expected to appear in court for sentencing on June 18.
Remembering the Victim
Matthew Ascaridis has been remembered by family and friends as a caring husband and a devoted father. Those who knew him described him as a warm and kind person who always welcomed others with a smile.
