Authorities in Florida have announced that they might seek the death penalty for Susan Avalon, a woman accused of murdering her two ex-husbands on the same day in December 2025. The killings occurred in Hillsborough and Manatee counties, sparking a significant investigation. Avalon now faces multiple charges in connection with the deaths of David Scott and Timothy Fletcher, who were both killed on December 17, 2025.
The Killings on December 17, 2025
On December 17, 2025, Susan Avalon allegedly shot her two ex-husbands in separate locations: David Scott in Bradenton and Timothy Fletcher in Tampa. The shootings occurred in quick succession, leading authorities to believe that Avalon killed Fletcher first, before traveling to Scott’s residence and killing him as well.
According to police reports, Scott, who was still alive when officers arrived, suggested that his ex-wife could have been the shooter. His daughter, who shared a child with Avalon, claimed to have heard gunshots and seen a vehicle driving away from the scene shortly after the shooting.
Authorities Track Avalon’s Movements
Using a description of the vehicle and other evidence, police were able to locate Avalon in Citrus County. When approached, Avalon allegedly responded to questions about her ex-husband by saying, “Which one?” This statement prompted investigators to conduct a welfare check on Fletcher, leading to the discovery of his body.
Charges and Legal Proceedings
Susan Avalon has been charged with first-degree premeditated murder in connection with Timothy Fletcher’s death and two counts of second-degree murder for David Scott’s killing. She has pleaded not guilty to all charges, and the Hillsborough County State Attorney’s Office has indicated they will pursue the death penalty against her.
The case has attracted attention due to the nature of the crime and the potential for a death sentence. As the legal proceedings unfold, authorities are continuing their investigation into the events of December 17, 2025.
