A deeply tragic case from Sedgwick County has shaken the community after a young pregnant woman was killed by her partner, leaving behind a baby girl with lifelong medical challenges. The incident shows how a moment of fear, control, and anger can destroy multiple lives forever.
Case Overview
A 20-year-old man, Matthew Criscenzo, has been sentenced to a total of 74 years in prison for killing his pregnant girlfriend, Naomi Oglesby. He was found guilty of premeditated first-degree murder, felony murder, kidnapping, and aggravated battery for the crime that took place in May 2024.
What Happened
According to investigators, the incident occurred at Criscenzo’s father’s home. The couple reportedly had an argument after Naomi said she wanted to leave. In that moment, Criscenzo pulled out a gun and shot her in the head. What started as a personal disagreement quickly turned into a fatal act.
Criscenzo later told police that he did not want her to leave and believed she was going to end the relationship. His statements after the incident showed shock, but the court focused on his actions and the consequences.
Eyewitness Account
Criscenzo’s father was inside the house at the time. He told police that he heard a gunshot and rushed out to see what had happened. He found Naomi lying on the ground while Criscenzo was standing nearby holding a gun. The father immediately took the weapon away and called emergency services. His account became a key part of the investigation.
Impact on the Baby
Naomi was 37 weeks pregnant when she was shot. Doctors performed an emergency C-section to save the baby. The child survived, but suffered severe brain damage due to lack of oxygen.
The baby now lives with serious health conditions, including cerebral palsy. According to her caregivers, she may never be able to eat normally or live an independent life. Her condition shows the long-term impact of the incident, not just on one life but on another innocent child.
Court Decision
The judge made it clear that the crime had devastating consequences. Criscenzo was sentenced to 74 years in prison, including a life sentence component. The court rejected requests for a lighter punishment.
Jeff Goering stated that if the baby had not survived, the case could have been treated as an even more serious capital offence.
Statements in Court
During the hearing, prosecutors said that Criscenzo’s actions were driven by control and anger. They pointed out that he ended Naomi’s life and permanently changed the future of their child.
Family members also spoke about the emotional loss and the challenges the baby will face. Naomi’s sister shared that the child’s life has been permanently affected and may never be normal.
Background Concerns
Investigators also found that the relationship had a history of problems. People close to the couple described Criscenzo as controlling and violent, with reports of threats made shortly before the incident.
The defence argued that he had mental health struggles and learning difficulties, but the court still held him fully responsible for his actions.
