Indiana may look like a quiet and simple Midwestern state, but behind its peaceful towns and green fields hides a much darker side. From haunted houses to creepy cemeteries, abandoned hospitals to ghost stories passed down for generations, Indiana is a hidden gem for lovers of the eerie, strange, and downright macabre. If you enjoy spine-chilling tales, mysterious places, and the feeling of being just a little bit scared, then this list is made for you. Here are 11 creepy spots in Indiana you’ll want to explore—if you dare.
Whispers Estate – The Haunted House in Mitchell
This 19th-century mansion is known as one of Indiana’s most haunted places. Visitors have reported ghost sightings, moving furniture, and strange whispers in empty rooms. The house was once home to a doctor and his family—and their spirits may still be there. You can book an overnight stay if you’re feeling brave.
Central State Hospital – Indianapolis’ Abandoned Asylum
Originally called the Indiana Hospital for the Insane, this large campus once treated mental health patients. Now, many of the old buildings are abandoned, and rumors say spirits of past patients still roam the halls. It’s not open to the public, but even driving past is enough to give you chills.
The Grave in the Middle of the Road – Amity, Indiana
Yes, it’s exactly what it sounds like. There’s a grave right in the middle of a road—and no one is allowed to move it. It belongs to Nancy Kerlin Barnett, and when a road was built over the cemetery, her family refused to have her remains relocated. Today, her grave stands proudly in the middle of a two-lane road.
Culbertson Mansion – Home of the Grisly Haunted House
In New Albany, this mansion turns into one of Indiana’s most terrifying haunted attractions every Halloween. But even without the fake scares, many believe the historic home is actually haunted. With dark halls, Victorian-era furniture, and ghost stories galore, it’s a spooky experience year-round.
Stepp Cemetery – Bloomington’s Forest of Shadows
Deep in the Morgan-Monroe State Forest lies Stepp Cemetery, a small and eerie place that locals say is full of paranormal energy. Some believe the spirit of a grieving mother still visits the grave of her child. Strange lights and sounds are often reported at night.
Indiana Medical History Museum – Where the Dead Still Speak
This museum, located on the grounds of the old Central State Hospital, displays medical tools, preserved brains, and old equipment used to study mental illness. It’s both educational and creepy, giving you a glimpse into the darker side of medical history.
Hannah House – The Underground Railroad Haunting
This Indianapolis home was once a stop on the Underground Railroad. A tragic fire in the basement killed several people hiding there, and some believe their spirits still linger. Many visitors report cold spots, whispers, and flickering lights during tours.
100 Steps Cemetery – The Graveyard with a Ghostly Challenge
In Brazil, Indiana (yes, that’s a real place), this old cemetery has a staircase legend. At night, if you climb the 100 steps and count aloud, you’ll see a ghost at the top who will show you a vision of your death. Walk back down, and if the number of steps has changed—bad luck is coming.
Rhodes Hotel – Where Ghost Hunters Go
Located in Atlanta, Indiana, the Rhodes Hotel has been featured in several paranormal investigations. Guests and staff have reported ghost sightings, children’s laughter when no kids are around, and objects moving on their own. It’s now open for ghost tours and overnight investigations.
University of Notre Dame – Ghosts on Campus?
This famous university isn’t just known for academics and football. There are several ghost stories tied to campus buildings, especially Washington Hall. Students have heard footsteps, seen flickering lights, and even felt unexplained cold drafts when no one else is around.
Tunnelton Tunnel – The Haunted Train Route
Near Bedford, this old train tunnel is said to be haunted by workers who died during its construction and by a decapitated train conductor whose ghost still walks the tracks. Locals say you can hear screams and footsteps echoing through the tunnel at night.
Indiana might not be the first place you think of when it comes to creepy travel spots, but for those who love the strange and mysterious, it’s full of hidden horror gems. From haunted mansions and eerie cemeteries to ghost-ridden tunnels and historic tragedies, the state offers a little scare for everyone. Whether you’re a ghost hunter, a history lover, or just curious, these 11 creepy destinations are sure to give you goosebumps. So pack your torch, bring a brave friend, and explore the haunted side of Indiana—just don’t go alone!
SOURCES
[1] https://history.howstuffworks.com/historical-events/haunted-places-in-indiana.htm
[2] https://www.visitindiana.com/best-of-indiana/winners/best-haunted-attractions/
[3] https://hannahauntedacres.com
[4] https://www.thirteenthhourindy.com
[5] https://www.reddit.com/r/indianapolis/comments/15sz2fq/weirdodd_macabre_unusual_things_to_do_in/
