Columbia, South Carolina, is home to a vibrant culinary scene that goes beyond the usual tourist fare, offering hidden gems that delight adventurous food lovers. Here are the top 5 hidden culinary gems in Columbia for 2025.
Top 5 Hidden Gems for Food Lovers
Mathias Sandwich Shop
A classic just outside downtown in Irmo, Mathias is renowned for Southern staples like pimento cheese and chicken salad sandwiches, served with an old-school meat-and-three buffet.
Goat’s
Nestled in a side street of Five Points, Goat’s has a quirky, welcoming vibe. Their standout dishes include the decadent Lobster Mac & Cheese and an impressive wine selection.
Il Giorgione
This cozy Italian spot on Devine Street is a neighborhood favorite for those seeking a quiet, authentic experience. Their handmade pastas and extensive wine list make it ideal for intimate dining.
SmallSUGAR
A tucked-away breakfast and lunch café downtown, SmallSUGAR is beloved for its local seasonal menu, standout pastries, breakfast tartines, and gourmet sandwiches.
Spotted Salamander
Hidden in Columbia’s historic district, this weekday lunch cafe is famed for creative Southern cuisine, such as their house bacon jam burgers and irresistible desserts.
Why These Spots Stand Out
Most of these gems are found in unassuming locations or neighborhoods that often fly under the radar for visitors, offering authentic, local flavors.
Menus emphasize homemade touches, Southern roots, and innovative twists, making them favorites among local foodies.
Exploring these lesser-known spots is the best way to taste Columbia’s unique culinary spirit in 2025.
SOURCES
[1](https://www.experiencecolumbiasc.com/blog/post/restaurants-off-the-beaten-path-in-columbia-sc/)
[2](https://whenincolumbia.com/best-restaurants-in-columbia/)
[3](https://www.opentable.com/neighborhood/sc/columbia-restaurants)
[4](https://www.instagram.com/reel/DPSHNnZD072/)
[5](https://www.experiencecolumbiasc.com/food-drink/)
