The City of Charleston is exploring options for the Coming Street Commons project, a redevelopment plan that would add 1,200 student housing beds on the site of the former YWCA and Potter’s Field. This proposal has sparked controversy, as the site is believed to be the burial ground for many enslaved Africans and indigenous people. To address these concerns, the City of Charleston’s Commission on History is dedicating the next few weeks to gathering more information and understanding the historical significance of the site.
A Unique Historical Opportunity
Commissioner Wilmont Fraser expressed the belief that learning more about the burial ground and addressing the challenges of historic preservation could turn the site into an important teaching opportunity. “We have something very unique in Charleston that can teach the world,” Fraser said, highlighting the potential for future history and preservation education.
Commission Approves Key Recommendations
At a recent meeting, the Commission on History voted to approve key recommendations from the Protect and Respect the Bodies coalitions. These recommendations include ensuring that descendants of those buried at the site have a voice in the redevelopment process and allowing the state agency responsible for burial sites to present their views.
College of Charleston’s Need for Housing
As the College of Charleston continues to expand its student population, the institution argues that affordable housing close to campus is crucial for enhancing the student experience. The Coming Street Commons project is seen by the college as a significant solution to this need for student housing.
A Delicate Balance Between Preservation and Development
In June, the City of Charleston granted the College of Charleston permission to demolish the former YWCA building. Commissioner Fraser emphasized the importance of proceeding with care, stating that further gathering of information and discussions at both the state and local levels are necessary to ensure the site is treated with respect for both the deceased and the living.
Advocacy for Responsible Redevelopment
Advocacy groups, including the Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC), are urging the city to guide the project through a thoughtful and transparent public process. Anna-Catherine Alexander of PSC stated that the city has a vital role to play in ensuring that community voices, especially those of descendants, are centered in the conversation about the redevelopment.
Public Engagement Opportunities
The College of Charleston is offering further opportunities for public engagement. They are inviting the community to attend a meeting on September 22 from 6-7 p.m. at 202 Calhoun Street to discuss the project and share feedback.
As the City of Charleston moves forward with the Coming Street Commons project, the balance between development and historical preservation remains a key focus for local officials and advocacy groups.
