A heartbreaking case out of Fishers, Indiana, where 17-year-old high school student Hailey Buzbee vanished on January 5, 2026, after sneaking out to meet 39-year-old Tyler N. Thomas from Columbus, Ohio—whom she connected with via an online gaming platform. Police now confirm her remains were recovered in Perry County, Ohio, after Thomas led authorities there; she’s believed to have died days after leaving home.​
Case Timeline
- Jan 5-6: Buzbee last seen at home ~10pm; parents report her missing next morning. Unknown vehicle in neighborhood traced to Thomas.
- Initial Contact: Thomas admits picking her up but claims he dropped her roadside in western Ohio—later proven false.
- Investigations: Searches of Thomas’s Columbus home, vehicle, and Hocking County rental yield evidence she was there, including deleted phone files with sexually explicit photos/videos of her (basis for charges).
- Feb 1: Fishers PD briefing declares her deceased; case shifts to recovery. FBI assists.
- Feb 1-2: Remains found in Perry County after Thomas cooperates; no murder charge yet, but expected.​
Current Charges and Status
Thomas faces felony counts of pandering sexually oriented matter involving a minor (Level 2) and tampering with evidence (Level 3) in Franklin County, Ohio.
Family and Community Response
Buzbee’s parents called her “smart, beautiful, kind” with a bright future; a GoFundMe hit $35K+ for support. Fishers Mayor Scott Fadness and Police Chief Ed Gebhart praised the “extensive” probe amid community heartbreak.
Online Safety Warnings
Cases like this underscore gaming platform risks for teens—predators groom via chats. FBI tips: Use privacy settings, tell parents about online friends, report suspicious contacts via CyberTipline.org. Initially a “runaway,” it escalated to endangered—vigilance saves lives. Tragic reminder for all families.
